Archive for November 17, 2026
WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS NEED TO RECOVER OUR EXCLUDED THIRD
0
While we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS have sometimes (, but rarely) used a form of LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZING that acknowledges our inclusion in “SOMETHING GREATER THAN OURSELVES”; e.g. propositons such as that by Brutus in Shakespeare’s “Julius Caesar” … “There is a tide in the affairs of men, Which, taken at the flood, leads on to fortune; Omitted, all the voyage of their life Is bound in shallows and in miseries. On such a full sea are we now afloat; And we must take the current when it serves, Or lose our ventures.” , WESTERN CULTURE COMMON PRACTICE has steadily shifted to the use of EGO-INFLATING grammar which imputes FULL and SOLE CREATIVE POWER to a LOCAL AUTHOR, so that we say “I gathered oysters from Nanoose Bay”, there is NO MENTION of waiting two weeks for a LOW TIDE which would acknowledge that we are living in a dynamic greater than ourselves, as overtly expressed by Chief Seattle and also by David Bohm;
Man did not weave the web of life, he is merely a strand in it. Whatever he does to the web, he does to himself.”
—Chief Seattle, …(this acknowledges that the operative logic is the BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM)
Modern physics reaffirms what Chief Seatle is saying, that we are included in the land we are looking out at, and messing around with.
Space is not empty. It is full, a plenum as opposed to a vacuum, and is the ground for the existence of everything, including ourselves.”
—David Bohm (this acknowledges that the operative logic is the BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM).
Once we acknowledge, in our linguistic conceptualizing scheme, THAT THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS “BEING” AND THAT EVERYTHING IS IN FLUX, we acknowledge ourselves to be CONDENSATIONS of the all-including energy-charged PLENUM
There is thus IMMENSE VALUE in GOING BEYOND “BEING” to “RELATIONS” in our Language and Thinking.
I am NOT SAYING that the LOCAL and EXPLICIT has ZERO VALUE, but I AM SAYING that we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS are PLAGUED by a current situation wherein we are cultivating LANGUAGE and THOUGHT which is the source of ABERRANT UNDERSTANDING. This is due to our MISTAKE of developing and using LANGUAGE that puts the LOCAL and EXPLICIT into an UNNATURAL PRIMACY OVER the NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT, the latter being PURELY RELATIONAL and UNENCUMBERED by the abstraction of “BEING” that is FOUNDATIONAL to LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZATION that is LOCAL and EXPLICIT.
We live in a world that is a transforming relational continuum, wherein everything is in flux, as affirmed in the philosophy of Heraclitus and endorsed by Nietzsche and Bohm and before thant, indigenous aboriginals, Taoists and Buddhists. For us (WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS) to have engineered a systems of LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZING and THINKING based on LOCAL and EXPLICIT MATERIAL BEING, together with, as Nietzsche points out, a DOUBLE ERROR of NAMING and GRAMMAR, is the source of ABERRANCE in our WESTERN CULTURE social dynamic.
Addressing this situation is challenged by the geometry of the situation which is akin to tryng to change the wheels on a car while speeding down the road in it. That is, and this has been pointed out by Bohm and by Zen scholar Alan Watts and by Wittgenstein and others, because we are living in a world that is a transforming relational continuum wherein everything is in continuing flux, our language and thought must be flow-based and capable of expressing the NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT (purely relational) … WITHOUT DEPENDENCE on the LOCAL and EXPLICIT of BEING-based CONCEPTUALIZATION.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) can play a role in helping us to inquire into our established practices, which is a bit like standing on our shoulders and critically scrutinizing, from a NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT perspective, our WESTERN CULTURE practice of giving priotity to the LOCAL and EXPLICIT. If we use the reference of Erich Jantsch’as THREE LEVELS of AWARENESS
The following AI Question and Answer uses the difference in understanding between SIMPLE BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM (Newtonian physics logic) and LESS SIMPLE NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM (modern physics logic). What is useful in this approach is that the user need not be, in advance, fully informed on the difference between the TWO types of logic, because the AI analysis is going to provide background information that will in itself be educational and beyond the level of ‘popular belief’. In this example, the AI interpretation goes BEYOND how a CONSERVATIVE and a LIBERAL would COMMONLY DIFFER in their understandings by bringing into play what Goedel’s Theorem would identify as the INCOMPLETENESS of their respective CONSERVATIVE and LIBERAL “PROPOSITIONS”. In other words, the AI recognizes the fact that NEITHER the CONSERVATIVE nor the LIBERAL is coming from “THE FULL STORY” and it is the DIFFERENT INCOMPLETENESSES that is the source of the CONFLICT in their respective understandings.
In otherwords, the CONSERVATIVES and the LIBERALS are BOTH CORRECT IN THEIR OWN UNDERSTANDINGS, the problem lies in fact that BOTH UNDERSTANDINGS ARE INCOMPLETE, but in DIFFERENT WAYS which the AI is capturing using the term BLINDSPOTS; i.e. the CONSERVATIVE propositions ARE CORRECT, just NOT COMPLETE (they have a CONSERVATIVE BLINDSPOT) and the LIBERAL propositions ARE CORRECT, just NOT COMPLETE (they have a LIBERAL BLINDSPOT). The RESULT, as stated in the AI Overview, is that “Because both sides view their framework as complete, they perceive the opposing side not as a complementary pole, but as an existential threat to truth.”
One might well ask, “If this is openly known, why do Conservatives and Liberals contintue to HEAD-BUTT?” The answer is; In WESTERN CULTURE, SIMPLE BINARY LOGIC CONTINUES TO BE THE GOLD STANDARD for LOGICAL INQUIRY AND ASSESSMENT and the division that we know as CONSERVATIVES (Tories) and LIBERALS (Whigs) derives from thinking that is simple BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM based, although what is needed is LESS SIMPLE NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM. Since the AI BOT has access to BOTH the less simple NONBINARY logic as well as to the simple BINARY logic, it has the tools for understanding that go beyond the understanding of the WARRING CONSERVATIVE and LIBERAL FACTIONS who are clearly hung-up on the use of SIMPLE BINARY LOGIC.
Most Recent Comments