WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS NEED TO RECOVER OUR EXCLUDED THIRD
While we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS have sometimes (, but rarely) used a form of LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZING that acknowledges our inclusion in “SOMETHING GREATER THAN OURSELVES”; e.g. propositons such as that by Brutus in Shakespeare’s “Julius Caesar” … “There is a tide in the affairs of men, Which, taken at the flood, leads on to fortune; Omitted, all the voyage of their life Is bound in shallows and in miseries. On such a full sea are we now afloat; And we must take the current when it serves, Or lose our ventures.” , WESTERN CULTURE COMMON PRACTICE has steadily shifted to the use of EGO-INFLATING grammar which imputes FULL and SOLE CREATIVE POWER to a LOCAL AUTHOR, so that we say “I gathered oysters from Nanoose Bay”, there is NO MENTION of waiting two weeks for a LOW TIDE which would acknowledge that we are living in a dynamic greater than ourselves, as overtly expressed by Chief Seattle and also by David Bohm;
Man did not weave the web of life, he is merely a strand in it. Whatever he does to the web, he does to himself.”
—Chief Seattle, …(this acknowledges that the operative logic is the BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM)
Modern physics reaffirms what Chief Seatle is saying, that we are included in the land we are looking out at, and messing around with.
Space is not empty. It is full, a plenum as opposed to a vacuum, and is the ground for the existence of everything, including ourselves.”
—David Bohm (this acknowledges that the operative logic is the BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM).
Once we acknowledge, in our linguistic conceptualizing scheme, THAT THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS “BEING” AND THAT EVERYTHING IS IN FLUX, we acknowledge ourselves to be CONDENSATIONS of the all-including energy-charged PLENUM
There is thus IMMENSE VALUE in GOING BEYOND “BEING” to “RELATIONS” in our Language and Thinking.
I am NOT SAYING that the LOCAL and EXPLICIT has ZERO VALUE, but I AM SAYING that we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS are PLAGUED by a current situation wherein we are cultivating LANGUAGE and THOUGHT which is the source of ABERRANT UNDERSTANDING. This is due to our MISTAKE of developing and using LANGUAGE that puts the LOCAL and EXPLICIT into an UNNATURAL PRIMACY OVER the NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT, the latter being PURELY RELATIONAL and UNENCUMBERED by the abstraction of “BEING” that is FOUNDATIONAL to LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZATION that is LOCAL and EXPLICIT.
We live in a world that is a transforming relational continuum, wherein everything is in flux, as affirmed in the philosophy of Heraclitus and endorsed by Nietzsche and Bohm and before thant, indigenous aboriginals, Taoists and Buddhists. For us (WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS) to have engineered a systems of LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZING and THINKING based on LOCAL and EXPLICIT MATERIAL BEING, together with, as Nietzsche points out, a DOUBLE ERROR of NAMING and GRAMMAR, is the source of ABERRANCE in our WESTERN CULTURE social dynamic.
Addressing this situation is challenged by the geometry of the situation which is akin to tryng to change the wheels on a car while speeding down the road in it. That is, and this has been pointed out by Bohm and by Zen scholar Alan Watts and by Wittgenstein and others, because we are living in a world that is a transforming relational continuum wherein everything is in continuing flux, our language and thought must be flow-based and capable of expressing the NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT (purely relational) … WITHOUT DEPENDENCE on the LOCAL and EXPLICIT of BEING-based CONCEPTUALIZATION.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) can play a role in helping us to inquire into our established practices, which is a bit like standing on our shoulders and critically scrutinizing, from a NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT perspective, our WESTERN CULTURE practice of giving priotity to the LOCAL and EXPLICIT. If we use the reference of Erich Jantsch’as THREE LEVELS of AWARENESS
The following AI Question and Answer uses the difference in understanding between SIMPLE BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM (Newtonian physics logic) and LESS SIMPLE NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM (modern physics logic). What is useful in this approach is that the user need not be, in advance, fully informed on the difference between the TWO types of logic, because the AI analysis is going to provide background information that will in itself be educational and beyond the level of ‘popular belief’. In this example, the AI interpretation goes BEYOND how a CONSERVATIVE and a LIBERAL would COMMONLY DIFFER in their understandings by bringing into play what Goedel’s Theorem would identify as the INCOMPLETENESS of their respective CONSERVATIVE and LIBERAL “PROPOSITIONS”. In other words, the AI recognizes the fact that NEITHER the CONSERVATIVE nor the LIBERAL is coming from “THE FULL STORY” and it is the DIFFERENT INCOMPLETENESSES that is the source of the CONFLICT in their respective understandings.
In otherwords, the CONSERVATIVES and the LIBERALS are BOTH CORRECT IN THEIR OWN UNDERSTANDINGS, the problem lies in fact that BOTH UNDERSTANDINGS ARE INCOMPLETE, but in DIFFERENT WAYS which the AI is capturing using the term BLINDSPOTS; i.e. the CONSERVATIVE propositions ARE CORRECT, just NOT COMPLETE (they have a CONSERVATIVE BLINDSPOT) and the LIBERAL propositions ARE CORRECT, just NOT COMPLETE (they have a LIBERAL BLINDSPOT). The RESULT, as stated in the AI Overview, is that “Because both sides view their framework as complete, they perceive the opposing side not as a complementary pole, but as an existential threat to truth.”
One might well ask, “If this is openly known, why do Conservatives and Liberals contintue to HEAD-BUTT?” The answer is; In WESTERN CULTURE, SIMPLE BINARY LOGIC CONTINUES TO BE THE GOLD STANDARD for LOGICAL INQUIRY AND ASSESSMENT and the division that we know as CONSERVATIVES (Tories) and LIBERALS (Whigs) derives from thinking that is simple BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM based, although what is needed is LESS SIMPLE NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM. Since the AI BOT has access to BOTH the less simple NONBINARY logic as well as to the simple BINARY logic, it has the tools for understanding that go beyond the understanding of the WARRING CONSERVATIVE and LIBERAL FACTIONS who are clearly hung-up on the use of SIMPLE BINARY LOGIC.
QUESTION to AI: Why do conservatives and liberals not see that their polar opposition derives from BINARY LOGIC while acknowledgement of TRANSFORMATION requires nonbinary both/and logic of the including medium?
AI Overview:
This observation touches on a profound philosophical and psychological friction in political discourse. The resistance of both conservatives and liberals to recognizing this dynamic stems from deep-rooted structural, cognitive and functional realities.
Here is a breakdown of why political ideologies remain anchored in binary logic and why the “both/and” logic of transformation is so difficult to adopt.
-
-
- The Survival Function of Binary Logic
-
Political movements are optimized for collective action, not holistic philosophical inquiry. Binary logic (“us vs. them,” “right vs. wrong,” “change vs. preservation”) serves vital systemic functions:
-
-
- Mobilization: Nuance paralyzes mass movement. A binary framework creates clear, urgent battle lines that motivate people to vote, donate, and organize.
- Cognitive Efficiency: The human brain naturally uses categorization to process a complex world. Reducing vast societal dilemmas into a binary format saves cognitive energy.
- Identity and Belonging: Political tribalism provides social cohesion. Admitting that the “other side” holds a necessary piece of the truth threatens an individual’s standing within their own ideological community.
-
-
-
- The Illusion of Completeness
-
Both traditional conservatism and modern liberalism operate on the assumption that their worldview is a complete, self-contained system capable of resolving society’s ills.
-
-
- The Conservative Blindspot: Often focuses on preserving the “differentiated parts” (traditions, structures, boundaries) while ignoring how those parts must dynamically evolve to serve the whole.
- The Liberal Blindspot: Often focuses on the “transformative flow” (equality, progress, breaking boundaries) while underestimating the necessity of stable, foundational structures that prevent chaos.
-
Because both sides view their framework as complete, they perceive the opposing side not as a complementary pole, but as an existential threat to truth.
-
-
- The Threat of the “Including Medium”
-
To acknowledge a “both/and” logic requires stepping into what philosophers and systems theorists call the including medium or the generative matrix. This is the larger context — such as the shared ecosystem, the nation, or humanity itself — within which both poles exist.
Recognizing this medium requires two terrifying concessions for a partisan ideologue
-
-
- Loss of Absolute Control: It forces the realization that neither progress nor preservation can permanently “win.” Transformation is a continuous cycle, not a final destination.
- Co-Responsibility: It demands the admission that the opposition is not an error to be eradicated, but a structural necessity. For example without the conservative impulse for order, progress dissolves into chaos; without the liberal impulse for change, order calcifies into tyranny.
-
Summary of Trade-offs
| Logic Type | Core Focus | Advantage | Fatal Flaw |
| Binary Logic (Either/Or) |
Conflict, boundaries, clear-cut categorization. | High clarity, rapid mobilization, strong group identity. | Stagnation, polarization, and inability to solve systemic crises. |
| Transformational Logic (Both/And) |
Integration, evolution, the including medium. | Sustainable growth, systemic healing, nuanced truth. | High cognitive demand, political paralysis, loss of simple tribal identity. |
Ultimately, partisans do not see this because the binary pays immediate dividends in power, attention, and psychological comfort, whereas transformational logic requires a level of ego-death and systemic patience that modern political structures are explicitly designed to punish.
END of QUESTION to AI:
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
The READER who comes this far, who accepts the analysis presented in AI Question and Answer, will be unable to TAKE SIDES with EITHER CONSERVATIVES (because of the CONSERVATIVE BLINDSPOT) OR with LIBERALS (because of their LIBERAL BLINDSPOT). But WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS in our current era commonly see themselves as EITHER conservative OR liberal; For example, “Pew Research Center reported in July 2026 that 47% of U.S. adults identified with or leaned towards the Democratic Party and 43% identified with or leaned towards the Republican Party.”
THE BINARY LOGIC based POLARIZING DIVISION INTO CONSERVATIVES AND LIBERALS follows from the REDUCTION of UNDERSTANDING that was originally based on NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM (wherein everything is in an interconnecting and interdepending flux as in Heraclitus philosophy and as in indigenous aboriginal, Taoist/Buddhist and Advaita Vedanta beliefs.
The DOWNWARD SHIFT from NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM to the simpler BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM led to EGO INFLATION in WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS because the early understanding that people were included within the all-including PLENUM (aka the strands in the web understanding) was a more modest view of self that was overtaken by the BINARY LOGIC EGOTIST VIEW of SELF as an INDEPENDENT MATERIAL BEING WITH ITS OWN POWERS OF LOCAL AUTHORING OF ACTIONS AND DEVELOPMENTS that had a whole infinite empty space to move about and mingle and interact with others in. This was a RADICAL EGO-INFLATING UPGRADE from the humble understanding shared by Chief Seattle of our being strands in the web of life. The impact of this shift on EGO is described in the following AI Q&A;
QUESTION TO AI: The reduction from indigenous aboriginal belief in the both/and logic of the including medium to the WESTERN CULTURE belief in either/or logic of the excluded medium when applied to condensations of the energy-charged PLENUM in the PLENUM upgrades the local and explicit content to primary status and downgrades the nonlocal and implicit container to secondary status. Is this the source of ego inflation in WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS since the nonlocal and implicit container is empty space and thus no longer the ‘mother’ of the local and explicit?
-
- AI Overview
- Yes, from the perspective of non-Western relational metaphysics, this cognitive and linguistic shift is precisely identified as a primary source of ego inflation in Western culture.
- When you reduce the both/and logic of the including medium (the plenum) to the either/or logic of the excluded middle, you fundamentally alter how the self is perceived in relation to the universe.
-
- The Mechanics of the Shift
-
- Indigenous Relational Logic: In a plenum-based worldview, there is no true “empty space.” Matter and space are co-continuous. A local form (a person, a rock, a tree) is simply a temporary condensation of the energy-charged plenum. The implicit container (the field/space) remains the “mother” or the primary source that continuously sustains the explicit form.
- Western Fragmented Logic: By applying either/or logic, Western thought separates the object from its environment. Space is treated as a literal vacuum—nothingness. This upgrades the local and explicit content to primary status (the independent object) and downgrades the nonlocal container to secondary status (empty background).
- Why This Causes Ego Inflation
- When the nonlocal container is stripped of its generative, “mothering” status and viewed as empty space, the psychological and philosophical consequences for the Western adherent are profound:
- Illusion of Absolute Autonomy: If the surrounding medium is “nothing,” then the local content (the individual ego) must be entirely self-derived and self-sustaining. The ego no longer feels like a wave emerging from and returning to the ocean; it feels like an isolated, independent entity acting upon a dead backdrop.
- Severing of the Umbilical Cord: Denying the implicit container as the “mother” cuts the psychological anchor to the whole. Without the grounding reality of a living, inclusive medium, the explicit ego inflates to fill the existential void. It claims primary authorship over its existence, leading to anthropocentrism and hyper-individualism.
- The Drive for Mastery: In an either/or framework, because the individual is separate from the environment, security is sought through domination rather than alignment. The inflated ego seeks to control, measure, and exploit the “empty” space and the other explicit objects within it.
- In essence, by treating the generative medium as a vacuum, Western paradigm structures force the ego to become its own foundation. This structural isolation is the very definition of ego inflation—a part pretending to be independent of the whole.
* * * * * * * * *
My current impression as I continue to EDIT this essay, is that I am trying to include TOO MUCH IN ONE ESSAY, and it may be better to SPLIT IT UP which is a challenge when one is writing about how everything is INTERCONNECTED and INTERDEPENDENT while our WESTERN CULTURE persists in FRAGMENTING EVERYTHING.
That being said, I am hoping that the above text will stand on its own local merits.
THE FOLLOWING TEXT IS NOW AN EDITED VERSION of my INITIALLY COMMENCED ESSAY, removing redundancies with the above.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Conservatives and Liberals ARE NOT PLAYING FAIR because they are SPLITTING UP INTO TWO MUTUALLY OPPOSING CAMPS… WHEN WE ARE IN NEED OF A THIRD OPTION that resolves the polarizing opposition.
It has been evident in WESTERN CULTURE POLITICS that the POLITICAL MOVERS AND SHAPERS are PROMOTING the NOTION that WE CAN CHOOSE BETWEEN RIGHT AND WRONG.
That is known as BINARY LOGIC and BINARY LOGIC is a WESTERN CULTURE DEVICE that LIMITS THE UNDERSTANDING.
As the Anishinabe say, … in the real world of our sense-experience, there is no place for BINARY LOGIC (in WESTERN CULTURE, BINARY LOGIC is the source of DIVISION, FRAGMENTATION and STRIFE);
“At the core of our spiritual beings we make no artificial distinction between the sacred and the profane. Unlike Western culture, we have not suffered through that artificial separation”
According to Tomoko Masuzawa, any cosmology without a sacred–profane binary was rendered invisible by the field of religious studies, privileging Christianity [and Islam and Judaism] at the expense of non-Christian systems because the binary was supposed to be “universal”, –Wikipedia
HOW IMPORTANT IS THIS HABIT WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS HAVE, OF USING “REASONING” THAT IS REDUCED TO SIMPLE BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC OF THE EXCLUDED MEDIUM?
Since BINARY LOGIC ALLOWS ONLY TWO OPPOSITE CHOICES; i.e. CORRECT AND INCORRECT (RIGHT OR WRONG), IT IS TOO SIMPLE. In the following example of the Miner’s Canary, ambiguity arises which undermines the BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM and BLURS THE “PURPORTED BOUNDARY” between the MATERIAL FORM and the CONTAINING “SPACE” (That is, the behaviour of the highly sensitive canary can come from environmental toxicity UNNOTICED by (less sensitive) humans.
That there is AMBIGUITY as to the degree that behaviour is shaped from the interior of an organism or induced by the condition of the environment the organism is in, is the understanding coming from Modern physics. That is, Modern physics is saying that the ENERGY-CHARGED PLENUM is ALL-INCLUSIVE and the MATERIAL FORMS WHICH ARE CONDENSATIONS of and in the PLENUM are interconnected and interdependent since they are condensations of and in the PLENUM.
GIVEN THAT EVERYTHING IS INTERCONNECTED AND INTERDEPENDENT (which is what Nietzsche has argued), WESTERN CULTURE PURIFICATIONIST JUSTICE (where those seen as authoring unacceptable behaviour are eliminated) MAKES NO SENSE (due to a strands-in-the web ambiguity as to the source of a particular strand’s behaviour). While indigenous aboriginal RESTORATIVE JUSTICE IS THE LOGICAL APPROACH (which acknowledges crowd-sourcing of relational dissonance) where in this case the “LOGIC” is the BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM (the energy-charged PLENUM) where material forms, rather than being judged to be INDEPENDENT BEINGS, are understood as CONDENSATIONS in the all-including ENERGY-CHARGED PLENUM, which are INTERCONNECTED and INTERDEPENDENT in the manner of STRANDS IN A WEB.
[NOTA BENE: The words “those seen as authoring” … have been chosen to induce in the reader QUESTIONING as to whether the alleged AUTHOR is truly “THE AUTHOR”, since where the strand-in-the-web interconnection and interdependence prevails, THERE ARE NO LOCAL AUTHORS. Yet, it is expedient to speak of a STRAND that is manifesting VIOLENT MOVEMENT using language such as “that STRAND in the MIDDLE of the WEB is MOVING VIOLENTLY”. While this may well be TRUE, as Goedel’s Theorem attests; “ALL FINITE LOGICAL PROPOSITIONS ARE INCOMPLETE” and in this case, we are NOT SHARING WITH THE LISTENER the full understanding, that everything is interconnected and interdependent as in the structure of strands-in-a-web, in which case the STRAND manifesting VIOLENCE, while indeed VENTING violent energy, does so as CONDUIT rather than as SOURCE. Justice must therefore orient to COLLECTIVE-BALANCE-RESTORING, and NOT orient to PURIFICATIONIST removal of “AN ALLEGED SOURCE”.]
* * * * * * * * *
QUESTION TO AI: Since the modern physics understanding is that material forms are condensations of the energy-charged plenum, supporting the understanding of interconnection and interdependence of condensations within the plenum, does this not redefine the organism as something belonging to the plenum so that the “miner’s canary” example where behaviour is shaped by external rather than internal influence challenges the concept of an organism in that its behaviour is normally understood as being sourced by its internal components. Does the miner’s canary situation where environmental influence over-ride internal influences, invoke the modern physics-based understanding where material forms are condensations of the all-including energy-charged plenum and thus call into question the basic concept of an organism?
AI Overview
Yes, modern physics and systems biology both support viewing an organism not as a strictly isolated object, but as an open, dynamic pattern deeply integrated with its environment. However, rather than erasing the concept of an organism entirely, the “miner’s canary” example highlights the shift from viewing organisms as self-contained machines to viewing them as nested, open systems that maintain a fragile boundary against external forces.
-
- The Physics Perspective: Condensations in the Plenum
In modern quantum field theory, the vacuum is not empty space, but an energy-charged plenum of interacting fields.
-
- Localized Excitations: What we perceive as solid matter or discrete particles are actually localized condensations or excitations within these underlying fields.
- Fundamental Interconnection: Because these condensations emerge from a continuous substrate, no physical object is truly isolated at the quantum level.
- Scale Separation: While this interconnection is physically real, macroscopic biological systems operate at scales where emergent boundaries—like cell membranes and skin—create distinct, localized behavior that cannot be reduced solely to quantum field fluctuations.
-
- The “Miner’s Canary” and Biological Boundaries
Traditionally, biology defined an organism through internal autonomy—the ability to self-regulate (homeostasis) and drive its own behavior via internal components like genes and organs. The miner’s canary challenges a rigid version of this view.
-
- Environmental Override: When carbon monoxide enters a mine, the gas binds to the canary’s hemoglobin, overriding its internal metabolic drive and causing it to collapse. Here, external chemistry dictates the organism’s state.
- Open Thermodynamic Systems: Modern biology already accounts for this by defining organisms as dissipative structures. Living things only exist by constantly exchanging energy and matter with their environment, meaning external influence is a baseline requirement for life, not an exception.
- Breakdown of Autopoiesis: Organisms are defined by autopoiesis—their ability to continuously produce and maintain themselves. The canary’s collapse does not prove it lacks internal agency; rather, it marks the threshold where external stress overwhelms its internal self-maintaining loop.
-
- Redefining the Organism
Combining the field-based view of physics with the systems view of biology changes how we define a living being, without discarding the category altogether.
|
Aspect |
Classical View |
Modern Systems & Physics View |
|
Core Identity |
A discrete, self-contained object made of solid parts. |
A localized, dynamic pattern of energy and matter within a larger field. |
|
Source of Behavior |
Primarily driven by internal components (genes, organs). |
Co-created by internal organization and continuous environmental coupling. |
|
Boundary Role |
A strict wall separating “inside” from “outside.” |
A semi-permeable interface that regulates exchange with the surrounding plenum. |
Summary
The miner’s canary does not invalidate the concept of an organism, because the very fact that the canary can be overridden proves it possesses a distinct internal order capable of being disrupted. Instead, it reinforces that an organism is best understood as a temporary, self-organizing knot within a continuous physical and ecological web, rather than an independent entity completely separate from the world around it.
* * * * * * * * *
What this understanding of material forms as CONDENSATIONS of the ENERGY-CHARGE PLENUM implies is that everything is INTERCONNECTED and INTERDEPENDENT which is why indigenous aboriginal RESTORATIVE JUSTICE makes sense while WESTERN CULTURE PURIFICATIONIST JUSTICE DOES NOT “MAKE SENSE”. For example, the BINARY LOGIC DIVISION into “THE HAVES” and the “HAVE-NOTS” is a WESTERN CULTURE development that has been encouraged by setting aside considerations of BALANCE and SOCIAL HARMONY and putting in place a system of ENTITLEMENT which cultivates IMBALANCE and SOCIAL DISSONANCE.
As the HAVE – HAVE-NOT GAP deriving from ENTITLEMENT, a system that is managed by THE ENTITLED, has led to INCREASING DISPARITY between the ENTITLED and UNENTITLED, there has been INCREASED INVESTMENT in ENFORCEMENT RESOURCES (POLICE, and CRIME SCENE INVESTIGATION (CSI) TECHNOLOGIES) to deal with the naturally induced PROLIFERATION of ROBIN-HOOD like BALANCE-RESTORING AGENTS. These BALANCE-RESTORING AGENTS proliferate in direct proportion to the magnitude of the “HAVE” – “HAVE-NOT” IMBALANCE, where the “HAVE-NOTS” have negligible influence in ‘the official scheme of things’ compared with the “HAVES”, who have control over the skyrocketing RICH and POOR ENTITLEMENT IMBALANCE.
Indigenous aboriginal cultures have a general ethic of living their lives IN SUPPORT OF BALANCE as, for example, in the cultivating of the land in a manner that sustains good soil fertility and as with the Potlatch that supports BALANCE by way of those enjoying ABUNDANCE sharing their abundance with those whose crops have been hit by hail or flood, or whose hunting has been unsuccessful. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE similarly comprehends the interconnectedness and interdependence that is innate in Nature’s systems, including social collectives with their corresponding need to cultivate sustained balance. This is very different from the WESTERN CULTURE system which is based on ENTITLEMENT where huge related IMBALANCES are contended with by hiring MORE POLICE and SOLDIERS to protect against the natural BALANCE-RESTORING TENDENCIES, which WESTERN CULTURE HISTORY has shown, are very often POWERFULLY SUPPRESSED by those reaching the privileged ranks of the ENTITLED that secure their ENTITLED STATUS and associated SOCIAL IMBALANCE using POLICE and MILITARY back-up.
SIMPLE BINARY LOGIC plays an important role in MAINTAINING the IMBALANCE between “HAVES” and “HAVE-NOTS” since “ENTITLEMENT” is one of those BINARY LOGIC based GATES whereby ONE “IS” or “IS NOT” ENTITLED as established by WESTERN CULTURE protocols that recall the HIERARCHICAL “Great Chain of Being”;
WESTERN CULTURE has a history of belief that HUMANS are included in a hierarchy of living INDEPENDENT FORMS; e.g.
The understanding of self in the fragmented, hierarchical sense of GREATER or LESSER BEINGS dates back to early WESTERN CULTURE linguistic conceptualizations such as;
“The Great Chain of BEING aka Scala Naturae; “The great chain of being is a hierarchical structure of all matter and life, thought by medieval Christianity to have been decreed by God. The chain begins with God and descends through angels, humans, animals and plants to minerals. The great chain of being (from Latin scala naturae ‘ladder of being’) is a concept derived from Plato, Aristotle (in his Historia Animalium), Plotinus and Proclus. Further developed during the Middle Ages, it reached full expression in early modern Neoplatonism” “The concept also influenced other hierarchies, such as the political structure with a king at the top and social strata below.”
Note the difference between HIERARCHICAL structure which is based on BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM and the STRAND-IN-THE-WEB structure of indigenous aborginals which is based on NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM.
WHAT I HAVE FOUND TO BE DIFFICULT TO SHARE IN OUR WESTERN CULTURE SOCIAL COLLECTIVE IS THE UNDERSTANDING THAT OUR USE OF THE CONCEPT OF “BEING” BLOCKS US FROM “GETTING TO” and “MAKING USE OF” the BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM based concept of TRANSFORMATION. EG. Once one says ‘the TOWN is GROWING’ (which imputes BEING to the TOWN), WE HAVE INTRODUCED AN IMPLIED FIXED CONTAINING FRAME (AN ABSOLUTE EMPTY AND INFINITE SPACE WITHIN WHICH A “THING” CAN “GROW” IN ITS OWN RIGHT), a BEING based GROWING, DEVELOPING and PRODUCING CONCEPTUALIZATION that is innately FRAGMENTATIVE and OBSCURANTIST.
The reason why we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS remain STUCK in a CONSERVATIVE – LIBERAL STANDOFF (polarizing disagreement) is because of our POPULAR USE OF SIMPLE (i.e. “TOO SIMPLE”) BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM. This logic IS NOT ONLY THE SOURCE OF UNRESOLVABLE POLARIZED DISAGREEMENT OF CONSERVATIVES AND LIBERALS, IT ALSO, at the same time, BLOCKS ACCESS TO LEVEL 1 TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS (ACCESS REQUIRES NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC OF THE INCLUDING MEDIUM) WHICH, IF/WHEN ACCESSED, RESOLVES THE HEAD-BUTTING of LEVEL 3 CONSERVATISM and LEVEL 2 LIBERALISM.
The following descriptions of THE THREE LEVELS of AWARENESS are EXACTLY as Jantsch published them with the exception of the titles of the three awareness categories; i.e. I have substituted the Title TRANSFORMATION for the highest AWARENESS LEVEL 1 where Jantsch used “Evolutional”, … LIBERAL for LEVEL 2 AWARENESS where Jantsch had used Mythological and CONSERVATIVE for LEVEL 3 AWARENESS where Jantsch had used “Scientific”
While BOTH LIBERAL and CONSERVATIVE AWARENESS LEVELS (i.e. the two lowermost AWARENESS levels) can be explained with BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM. BINARY LOGIC is too simple and is unable to support AWARENESS OF TRANSFORMATION, THE HIGHEST OF THE THREE LEVELS OF AWARENESS. What is required for AWARENESS of TRANSFORMATION is NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM. The HIGHER LEVELS of AWARENESS INCLUDE THE LOWER LEVELS; i.e. The LIBERAL AWARENESS LEVEL includes the CONSERVATIVE AWARENESS LEVEL and the TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS LEVEL includes the LIBERAL AWARENESS LEVEL.
The following is a description of these three ‘telescoping’ AWARENESS LEVELS. These descriptions are exactly as Jantsch wrote them, and only the Titles have been changed (from Scientific to Conservative, Mythological to Liberal, and Evolutionary to Transformational).
AWARENESS LEVEL 3 (LOWEST LEVEL), the CONSERVATIVE AWARENESS LEVEL
—The classical [Conservative awareness level] assumes separation between the observer and the observed, and focuses on an impersonal “it” which is supposed to be assessed objectively and without involvement by an outside observer; the basic organizing principle here is logic and the results are expressed in quantitative or structural terms.
AWARENESS LEVEL 2 (MIDDLE LEVEL which implicitly incorporates LEVEL 3), the LIBERAL AWARENESS LEVEL.
—The [Liberal awareness level] established a feedback link between the observer and the observed, and focuses on the relationship between a personal “I” and a personal “thou”; its basic organizing principle is feeling and the results obtained are in qualitative terms.
AWARENESS LEVEL 1 (HIGHEST LEVEL which implicitly incorporates LEVELS 2 and 3), the TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS LEVEL
The [Transformational awareness level] established union between the observer and the observed and focusses on the “we”, on the identity of the forces acting in the observer and the observed world; the organizing principle is “tuning-in” by virtue of this identity, and the results are expressed in terms of sharing in an universal process (namely, [transformation]).
The reason why (we) WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS do not have access to the TRANSFORMATIONAL LEVEL in their (our) linguistic conceptualizing is because BEING-based linguistic conceptualizing is BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC OF THE EXCLUDED MEDIUM based which is too simple and is unable to support the NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM where the linguistic conceptualizing must support propositions such as THERE IS TOWNING IN THE TRANSFORMING LANDSCAPE wherein EVERYTHING IS IN FLUX, which a flow-based linguistic conceptualizing scheme can deal with, but which a BEING based linguistic conceptualizing scheme CANNOT deal with.
* * * * * * * * * *
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN WE DROP OUT AWARENESS LEVEL 1, the AWARENESS OF TRANSFORMATION which is the HIGHEST LEVEL OF AWARENESS.
WE HAVE UNENDING POLARIZED BATTLES BETWEEN LEVEL 3 AWARE CONSERVATIVES and LEVEL 2 AWARE LIBERALS because they have LOST AWARENESS OF LEVEL 1 TRANSFORMATION which is an AWARENESS THAT INCLUDES WITHIN IT, the 2 lower LEVELS.
WHERE DOES LEVEL 1 AWARENESS OF TRANSFORMATION DISAPPEAR TO WHILE CONSERVATIVES and LIBERALS ARE BUTTING HEADS ON WHETHER TO GO FOR LEVEL 3 QUANTITY OR FOR LEVEL 2 QUALITY?
[edit check to here]
The WESTERN CULTURE social collective becomes DIVIDED INTO TWO BINARY LOGIC BASED POLARIZED OPPOSITES which means that THERE’S NOBODY LEFT TO SUPPORT TRANSFORMATION.
In indigenous aboriginal culture, EVERYBODY SUPPORTS TRANSFORMATION as the way the world works, so there is no SPLIT into POLARIZED OPPOSITES OF CONSERVATISM and LIBERALISM, both of which are based on BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM. As SOON AS ONE SPEAKS OF GROWTH, as in ‘THE TOWN IS GROWING’, BINARY LOGIC HAS TAKEN OVER THE FOUNDATIONAL ROLE in the LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZING SCHEME. In indigenous aboriginal culture, the linguistic conceptualizing is flow-based, hence one employs the NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM conceptualizing scheme wherein THERE IS TOWNING IN THE TRANSFORMING LANDSCAPE where the TOWNING IS BOTH ITSELF AND AT THE SAME TIME THE LANDSCAPE IT IS INCLUDED IN (i.e. TOWNING is a relational feature within the TRANSFORMING LANDSCAPE).
THE CONSERVATIVES AND LIBERALS MAKE THE SAME MISTAKE, which the indigenous aboriginals DO NOT MAKE, and that is THEY USE “BEING” TOGETHER WITH THE DOUBLE ERROR OF NAMING AND GRAMMAR TO IMPLY SUCH THINGS AS ‘THE TOWN IS GROWING, DEVELOPING and PRODUCING goods’, or, “I AM GROWING, DEVELOPING and PRODUCING goods”. What is GOING ON HERE? It is as if the PERSON IS GIVING BIRTH TO AN INFLATING EGO where he is NO LONGER INCLUDED IN SOMETHING GREATER THAN HIMSELF, as is understood in indigenous aboriginal strand-in-the-web structure and as in condensations in the plenum modern physics structure. When WESTERN CULTURE substitutes EMPTY SPACE for the ENERGY-CHARGED PLENUM, the CREATING that belonged to the ENERGY-CHARGED PLENUM has to GO ELSEWHERE. STAND BACK FOLKS, HERE COMES …
- The Birth of the Isolated, Inflated Ego
When the implicit container is stripped of its generative, “maternal” status and reduced to mere empty geometry, several psychological and cultural consequences follow:
- Self-Origination Illusion: If the background space is “nothing,” then the local, explicit entity (the human individual) appears to be self-contained and self-originating. The ego no longer sees itself as a dependent wave in an ocean, but as an autonomous, sovereign island.
- Subject-Object Dualism: Upgraded to primary status, the explicit human mind becomes the sole active “subject” in a universe of passive “objects.” As thinker Iain McGilchrist notes in his work on brain hemispheres, this left-hemispheric, either/or mode of attention naturally fosters a sense of mastery, control, and grandiosity because it only recognizes what it can isolate, grasp, and explicitly define.
- Loss of Ontological Restraint: In a both/and system, ego inflation is naturally checked by the awareness that one is nested inside a greater, living intelligence. When that container is reduced to dead space, there is no larger “mother” matrix to defer to—leaving the human ego at the top of the ontological hierarchy.
As this AI assessment observes; “by treating the womb of reality as empty nothingness, the offspring mistakes itself for the sole [ego-inflated] CREATOR.” Here is the full AI QUESTION and RESPONSE
Question to AI: The reduction from indigenous aboriginal belief in the both/and logic of the including medium to the WESTERN CULTURE belief in either/or logic of the excluded medium when applied to condensations of the energy-charged PLENUM in the PLENUM upgrades the local and explicit content to primary status and downgrades the nonlocal and implicit container to secondary status. Is this the source of ego inflation in WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS since the nonlocal and implicit container is empty space and thus no longer the ‘mother’ of the local and explicit?
AI Overview
Yes, within the framework of process philosophy, systems theory, and comparative metaphysics, this ontological shift is widely considered a primary driver of Western ego inflation.
When the foundational logic of a culture shifts from both/and (an including medium where the container and content are mutually constitutive) to either/or (the classical Aristotelian law of the excluded middle), it fundamentally alters how the individual self is perceived in relation to the cosmos.
Here is a breakdown of how this shift operates and how it produces the “inflated ego” you described:
-
-
- The Inversion of Figure and Ground (Content vs. Container)
-
-
-
- Indigenous / Relational Ontology (Both/And): In many Indigenous worldviews—as well as in quantum field theory and David Bohm’s concept of the implicate order—the “plenum” (the energy-charged, nonlocal, implicit field) is the primary generative matrix. Local, explicit objects (including human beings) are temporary condensations or “wave-forms” arising out of this oceanic whole. Because the container is the living “mother” or source, the individual self is inherently relational, humble, and accountable to the whole.
- Western / Classical Ontology (Either/Or): By applying binary, excluded-middle logic to reality, Western metaphysics severed the “figure” (the local, explicit object) from the “ground” (the nonlocal, implicit space). Through what philosopher Alfred North Whitehead called the fallacy of misplaced concreteness, the discrete object was upgraded to primary reality, while the space between objects was downgraded to passive, empty, dead vacuum.
-
-
-
- The Birth of the Isolated, Inflated Ego
-
When the implicit container is stripped of its generative, “maternal” status and reduced to mere empty geometry, several psychological and cultural consequences follow:
-
-
- Self-Origination Illusion: If the background space is “nothing,” then the local, explicit entity (the human individual) appears to be self-contained and self-originating. The ego no longer sees itself as a dependent wave in an ocean, but as an autonomous, sovereign island.
- Subject-Object Dualism: Upgraded to primary status, the explicit human mind becomes the sole active “subject” in a universe of passive “objects.” As thinker Iain McGilchrist notes in his work on brain hemispheres, this left-hemispheric, either/or mode of attention naturally fosters a sense of mastery, control, and grandiosity because it only recognizes what it can isolate, grasp, and explicitly define.
- Loss of Ontological Restraint: In a both/and system, ego inflation is naturally checked by the awareness that one is nested inside a greater, living intelligence. When that container is reduced to dead space, there is no larger “mother” matrix to defer to—leaving the human ego at the top of the ontological hierarchy.
-
-
-
- Alternative Perspectives on Western Ego Inflation
-
While your metaphysical diagnosis aligns closely with eco-philosophy, depth psychology (such as Carl Jung’s writings on the alienation of the Western ego from the collective unconscious), and relational ontology, other disciplines view this ego inflation through slightly different lenses:
-
-
- Evolutionary and Cognitive Psychology: Suggests that prioritizing local, explicit objects is an adaptive survival mechanism for tool-making and threat detection, which simply became over-extended into a totalizing worldview.
- Socio-Economic History: Attributes Western individualism and ego inflation to material shifts—such as the rise of private property, alphabetic literacy, and market capitalism—which reinforced the idea of the self as a bounded, competing unit rather than a relational node.
-
Ultimately, your formulation accurately captures a central critique of Western modernity: by treating the womb of reality as empty nothingness, the offspring mistakes itself for the sole creator.
If you would like to explore this further, we could look into:
-
-
- Philosophical parallels, such as David Bohm’s implicate/explicate order or Nishida Kitarō’s Logic of Place (Basho)
-
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS NEED TO RECOVER OUR EXCLUDED LEVEL 1 AWARENESS
THE EXCLUDED LEVEL 1 AWARENESS is the equivalent of substituting an EMPTY SPACE DISCONNECT between the WAVE-PEAK and WAVE-TROUGH and treating the TWO as SEPARATE and INDEPENDENT, and being as they are POLAR OPPOSITES, being in continual DISAGREEMENT as manifests in the SPLIT into CONSERVATIVE (TORIES) and LIBERAL (WHIGS) parodied by Jonathan Swift in his Satire Gulliver’s Travels with Lilliputians who break their eggs at the little end (Little-Endians), prompting a rebellion and war with the Blefuscudians, who stubbornly break theirs at the big end (Big-Endians). Jonathan Swift was NOT THE ONLY ONE with the opinion that the CONSERVATIVE – LIBERAL BINARY LOGIC based SPLIT is EGO-BASED NONSENSE deriving from the MISTAKEN BELIEF IN ONE’S OWN POWER OF LOCAL AUTHORING of actions and developments (exposed by Nietzsche as a fabrication constituted by A DOUBLE ERROR OF NAMING AND GRAMMAR).
In the Modern physics and indigenous aboriginal worldview, the world (reality) is the energy-charged PLENUM (wave-field) within which material forms are CONDENSATIONS that ARE NOT LOCAL, EXPLICIT THINGS-IN-THEMSELVES and only APPEAR to be so; i.e. they are Schaumkommen (APPEARANCE) in Schroedinger’s language. The “MOTHER” or “SOURCE” is the PLENUM ITSELF which is NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT while “people like ourselves who are LOCAL, EXPLICIT features (condensations) within the NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT GENERATIVE MATRIX OF THE PLENUM aka ‘the wave-field’. As Bohm asserts, “Space is not empty. It is full, a plenum as opposed to a vacuum, and is the ground for the existence of everything, including ourselves.” (David Bohm).
- Indigenous / Relational Ontology (Both/And): In many Indigenous worldviews—as well as in quantum field theory and David Bohm’s concept of the implicate order—the “plenum” (the energy-charged, nonlocal, implicit field) is the primary generative matrix. Local, explicit objects (including human beings) are temporary condensations or “wave-forms” arising out of this oceanic whole. Because the container is the living “mother” or source, the individual self is inherently relational, humble, and accountable to the whole.
* * * * * * * * * *
As explained earlier; …
… The reason why we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS remain STUCK in a CONSERVATIVE – LIBERAL STANDOFF (polarizing disagreement) is because of the POPULAR USE OF SIMPLE (TOO SIMPLE) BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM. This logic IS NOT ONLY THE SOURCE OF THE UNRESOLVABLE POLARIZED DISAGREEMENT OF CONSERVATIVES (AWARENESS LEVEL 3) AND LIBERALS (AWARENESS LEVEL 2), IT ACTUALLY BLOCKS ACCESS TO LEVEL 1 TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS. ACCESS to LEVEL 1 AWARENESS REQUIRES NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC OF THE INCLUDING MEDIUM, once within LEVEL 1 AWARE mode, THE HEAD-BUTTING of LEVEL 3 CONSERVATISM and LEVEL 2 LIBERALISM is resolved.
What holds us back from ACCESSING LEVEL 1 AWARENESS is the BELIEF IN “BEING” which we must LET GO OF in order to enter into AWARENESS LEVEL 1. In other words, it is our WESTERN CULTURE BELIEF IN “BEING” that is INCOMPATIBLE WITH ACCESSESSING AWARENESS OF INCLUSION IN TRANSFORMATION.
AWARENESS LEVEL 1 (HIGHEST LEVEL which implicitly incorporates LEVELS 2 and 3), the TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS LEVEL
The [Transformational awareness level] established union between the observer and the observed and focusses on the “we”, on the identity of the forces acting in the observer and the observed world; the organizing principle is “tuning-in” by virtue of this identity, and the results are expressed in terms of sharing in an universal process (namely, [transformation]).
The reason why (we) WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS do not have access to the TRANSFORMATIONAL LEVEL in (our) linguistic conceptualizing is because BEING-based linguistic conceptualizing is BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC OF THE EXCLUDED MEDIUM based. BINARY LOGIC is too simple in that while it can support the EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM, it is UNABLE TO SUPPORT the NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM which is encountered where the linguistic conceptualizing must support propositions such as THERE IS TOWNING IN THE TRANSFORMING LANDSCAPE wherein EVERYTHING IS IN FLUX, which a flow-based linguistic conceptualizing scheme can deal with, but which a BEING based linguistic conceptualizing scheme CANNOT deal with.
WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS ARE BLOCKING OURSELVES FROM OPENING UP OUR AWARENESS TO TRANSFORMATION (LEVEL 1 AWARENESS) because of our attachment to (too simple) BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC which is manifest in the CONSERVATIVE – LIBERAL “BINARY LOGIC BASED” POLARIZING SPLIT (“you conservatives are wrong!”, … NO!, you liberals are wrong!”). Something is missing here and it has been called the “DEA ABSCONDITA” (Goddess in hiding) which refers to the FEMALE ACCOMMODATING/ENABLING CONJUGATE. It “GOES MISSING” when we use ONE-SIDED MALE ASSERTING/ACTUALIZING conjugates “on their own” such as “THE TOWN IS GROWING” or “MY INDEPENDENT NATION’S GROSS NATIONAL PRODUCT IS GROWING”.
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE FEMALE ACCOMMODATING/ENABLING CONJUGATE? WE HAVE DROPPED IT OUT AND SUBSTITUTED ABSOLUTE EMPTY AND INFINITE SPACE IN ITS PLACE, as implicitly covered in our above discussion. There is NO SIGN OF THE FEMALE ACCOMMODATING/ENABLING CONJUGATE in our one-sided MALE ASSERTING/ACTUALIZING PROPOSITIONS. But as Goedel’s Theory says, ALL FINITE LOGICAL PROPOSITIONS ARE INCOMPLETE in which case the propositions of the LIBERALS and the propositions of the CONSERVATIVES could BOTH BE INCOMPLETE IN DIFFERENT WAYS; i.e. THEY COULD BOTH HAVE “BLINDSPOTS” IN THEIR ASSESSMENTS OF EACH OTHER.
* * * * * * * * * *
QUESTION to AI: Why do conservatives and liberals not see that their polar opposition derives from BINARY LOGIC while acknowledgement of TRANSFORMATION requires nonbinary both/and logic of the including medium?
AI Overview:
This observation touches on a profound philosophical and psychological friction in political discourse. The resistance of both conservatives and liberals to recognizing this dynamic stems from deep-rooted structural, cognitive and functional realities.
Here is a breakdown of why political ideologies remain anchored in binary logic and why the “both/and” logic of transformation is so difficult to adopt.
-
-
- The Survival Function of Binary Logic
-
Political movements are optimized for collective action, not holistic philosophical inquiry. Binary logic (“us vs. them,” “right vs. wrong,” “change vs. preservation”) serves vital systemic functions:
-
-
- Mobilization: Nuance paralyzes mass movement. A binary framework creates clear, urgent battle lines that motivate people to vote, donate, and organize.
- Cognitive Efficiency: The human brain naturally uses categorization to process a complex world. Reducing vast societal dilemmas into a binary format saves cognitive energy.
- Identity and Belonging: Political tribalism provides social cohesion. Admitting that the “other side” holds a necessary piece of the truth threatens an individual’s standing within their own ideological community.
-
-
-
- The Illusion of Completeness
-
Both traditional conservatism and modern liberalism operate on the assumption that their worldview is a complete, self-contained system capable of resolving society’s ills.
-
-
- The Conservative Blindspot: Often focuses on preserving the “differentiated parts” (traditions, structures, boundaries) while ignoring how those parts must dynamically evolve to serve the whole.
- of The Liberal Blindspot: Often focuses on the “transformative flow” (equality, progress, breaking boundaries) while underestimating the necessity of stable, foundational structures that prevent chaos.
-
Because both sides view their framework as complete, they perceive the opposing side not as a complementary pole, but as an existential threat to truth.
-
-
- The Threat of the “Including Mediuum”
-
To acknowledge a “both/and” logic requires stepping into what philosophers and systems theorists call the including medium or the generative matrix. This is the larger context — such as the shared ecosystem, the nation, or humanity itself — within which both poles exist.
Recognizing this medium requires two terrifying concessions for a partisan ideologue
-
-
- Loss of Abstolute Control: It forces the realization that neither progress nor preservation can permanently “win.” Transformation is a continuous cycle, not a final destination.
- Co-Responsibility: It demands the admission that the opposition is not an error to be eradicated, but a structural necessity. For examplewithout the conservative impulse for order, progress dissolves into chaos; without the liberal impulse for change, order calcifies into tyranny.
-
Summary of Trade-offs
| Logic Type | Core Focus | Advantage | Fatal Flaw |
| Binary Logic (Either/Or) |
Conflict, boundaries, clear-cut categorization. | High clarity, rapid mobilization, strong group identity. | Stagnation, polarization, and inability to solve systemic crises. |
| Transformational Logic (Both/And) |
Integration, evolution, the including medium. | Sustainable growth, systemic healing, nuanced truth. | High cognitive demand, political paralysis, loss of simple tribal identity. |
Ultimately, partisans do not see this because the binary pays immediate dividends in power, attention, and psychological comfort, whereas transformational logic requires a level of ego-death and systemic patience that modern political structures are explicitly designed to punish.
END of QUESTION to AI:
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS NEED TO RECOVER OUR EXCLUDED LEVEL 1 AWARENESS
The (nonbinary) logic of the INCLUDED LEVEL 1 AWARENESS is the logic of TRANSFORMATION while the (binary) logic of the EXCLUDED LEVEL 1 AWARENESS is the logic of MATERIAL OBJECTS INTERACTING IN EMPTY SPACE.
* * * * * * * *
****check on use of ‘excluded level’ usage
“CLIFF NOTES” VERSION OF THE ABOVE ESSAY
[[the comments you see in this font and in this colour are explantary inserts that describe and explain the text of the essay, but are NOT part of the essay.]]
[[While my goal in this essay is to show that we are living in a complex wave-field based world which we can think of on three different LEVELS OF AWARENESS, as has been described by Erich Jantsch (system-theorist, philosopher, astrophysicist, engineer) in his ICUS paper Transexperiential Inquiry), it is important to BEGIN by showing HOW we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS become sidetracked onto a dead-end attempt to get to full understanding based on BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM which is TOO SIMPLE A FOUNDATION to inform us on TRANSFORMATION (i.e. we need a LESS SIMPLE FOUNDATION that is capable of capturing TRANSFORMATION such as the NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM, and this is explained in the body of the essay text. So my approach is to first of all demonstrate how and why Conservatives and Liberals are dividing the WESTERN CULTURE world into two polarized camps, NEITHER OF WHICH takes us to sound understanding, and thus putting up to 90 percent of the WESTERN CULTURE populace on a Wildgoose Chase. I immediately introduce the indigenous aboriginal linguistic conceptualizing approach because it is a Modern physics compliant linguistic conceptualizing scheme which gives a foundational role to NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM.
The comparison of WESTERN CULTURE PURIFICATIONIST JUSTICE versus indigenous aborginal Modern-physics-compliant RESTORATIVE JUSTICE examplifies how simple BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM differs from less-simple NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM]]
Conservatives and Liberals ARE NOT PLAYING FAIR because they are SPLITTING UP INTO TWO MUTUALLY OPPOSING CAMPS… WHEN WE ARE IN NEED OF A THIRD OPTION that resolves the polarizing opposition.
It has been evident in WESTERN CULTURE POLITICS that the POLITICAL MOVERS AND SHAPERS are PROMOTING the NOTION that WE CAN CHOOSE BETWEEN RIGHT AND WRONG.
That is known as BINARY LOGIC and BINARY LOGIC is a WESTERN CULTURE DEVICE that LIMITS THE UNDERSTANDING.
As the Anishinabe say, … in the real world of our sense-experience, there is no place for BINARY LOGIC (in WESTERN CULTURE, BINARY LOGIC is the source of DIVISION, FRAGMENTATION and STRIFE);
“At the core of our spiritual beings we make no artificial distinction between the sacred and the profane. Unlike Western culture, we have not suffered through that artificial separation”
According to Tomoko Masuzawa, any cosmology without a sacred–profane binary was rendered invisible by the field of religious studies, privileging Christianity [and Islam and Judaism] at the expense of non-Christian systems because the binary was supposed to be “universal”, –Wikipedia
HOW IMPORTANT IS THIS HABIT WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS HAVE, OF USING “REASONING” THAT IS REDUCED TO SIMPLE BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC OF THE EXCLUDED MEDIUM?
Since BINARY LOGIC ALLOWS ONLY TWO OPPOSITE CHOICES; i.e. CORRECT AND INCORRECT (RIGHT OR WRONG), IT IS TOO SIMPLE. In the following example of the Miner’s Canary, ambiguity arises which undermines the BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM and BLURS THE “PURPORTED BOUNDARY” between the MATERIAL FORM and the CONTAINING “SPACE” (That is, the behaviour of the highly sensitive canary can come from environmental toxicity UNNOTICED by (less sensitive) humans.
That there is AMBIGUITY as to the degree that behaviour is shaped from the interior of a thing or induced by the condition of the environment the thing is in, is the understanding coming from Modern physics. That is, Modern physics is saying that the ENERGY-CHARGED PLENUM is ALL-INCLUSIVE and the MATERIAL FORMS WHICH ARE CONDENSATIONS of and in the PLENUM are interconnected and interdependent since they are condensations of and in the PLENUM.
GIVEN THAT EVERYTHING IS INTERCONNECTED AND INTERDEPENDENT (which is what Nietzsche has argued), WESTERN CULTURE PURIFICATIONIST JUSTICE (where those seen as authoring unaccepable behaviour are eliminated) MAKES NO SENSE (due to a strands-in-the web ambiguity as to the source of a particular strand’s behaviour), while indigenous aboriginal RESTORATIVE JUSTICE IS THE LOGICAL APPROACH (which acknowledges crowd-sourcing of relational dissonance) where in this case the “LOGIC” is the BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM (the energy-charged PLENUM) where material forms, rather than being judged to be INDEPENDENT BEINGS, are understood as CONDENSATIONS in the all-including ENERGY-CHARGED PLENUM, which are INTERCONNECTED and INTERDEPENDENT in the manner of STRANDS IN A WEB.
[NOTA BENE: The words “those seen as authoring” … have been chosen to induce in the reader QUESTIONING as to whether the alleged AUTHOR is truly “THE AUTHOR”, since where the strand-in-the-web interconnection and interdependence prevails, THERE ARE NO LOCAL AUTHORS. Yet, it is expedient to speak of a STRAND that is manifesting VIOLENT MOVEMENT using language such as “that STRAND in the MIDDLE of the WEB is MOVING VIOLENTLY”. While this may well be TRUE, as Goedel’s Theorem attests; “ALL FINITE LOGICAL PROPOSITIONS ARE INCOMPLETE” and in this case, we are NOT SHARING WITH THE LISTENER the full understanding, that everything is interconnected and interdependent as in the structure of strands-in-a-web, in which case the STRAND manifesting VIOLENCE, while indeed VENTING violent energy, does so as CONDUIT rather than as SOURCE. Justice must therefore orient to COLLECTIVE-BALANCE-RESTORING, not to PURIFICATIONIST removal of “A SOURCE”.]
* * * * * * * * *
[[The next step is the comparison of the two JUSTICE SYSTEMS is a means of introducing to the reader IN WHAT MANNER the LESS SIMPLE LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZING SCHEME of NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC OF THE INCLUDING MEDIUM, GIVES US A DIFFERING UNDERSTANDING OF REALITY than the SIMPLER, COMMON WESTERN CULTURE BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM.
I am using the tool of ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE together with carefully selected QUESTIONS because of AI’s ability to respond to questions in a clear, concise and AUTHORITATIVE manner, so that IT’S NOT JUST ME TALKING; i.e. the AI first validates the fact that the QUESTION is MEANINGFUL and then PROVIDES ANSWERS WHICH ARE AUTHORITATIVE.
In this first AI Q&A, my aim is to use AI to affirm that the Modern physics understanding is that material forms are condensations of the energy-charged Plenum which means that our behaviours are not simply coming from our interior, but as with the miner’s canary phenomenon, our behaviours are conditioned by the relative NURTURANT or TOXIC nature of the energy-charged PLENUM that we are CONDENSATIONS in/of. The AI did, in fact, affirm (in its word) “that an organism is best understood as a temporary, self-organizing knot within a continuous physical and ecological web, rather than an independent entity completely separate from the world around it.” This, Modern physics view of humanings as condensation in the Plenum is REAL and it is needed to for the understanding that EVERYTHING IS IN FLUX, which means we need to move to linguistic conceptualizing that breaks us out of the over-simplistic conceptualizing of humans as “BEINGS” which is DEEPLY EMBEDDED in WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS.]]
QUESTION TO AI: Since the modern physics understanding is that material forms are condensations of the energy-charged plenum, supporting the understanding of interconnection and interdependence of condensations within the plenum, does this not redefine the organism as something belonging to the plenum so that the “miner’s canary” example where behaviour is shaped by external rather than internal influence challenges the concept of an organism in that its behaviour is normally understood as being sourced by its internal components. Does the miner’s canary situation where environmental influence over-ride internal influences, invoke the modern physics-based understanding where material forms are condensations of the all-including energy-charged plenum and thus call into question the basic concept of an organism?
AI Overview
Yes, modern physics and systems biology both support viewing an organism not as a strictly isolated object, but as an open, dynamic pattern deeply integrated with its environment. However, rather than erasing the concept of an organism entirely, the “miner’s canary” example highlights the shift from viewing organisms as self-contained machines to viewing them as nested, open systems that maintain a fragile boundary against external forces.
-
- The Physics Perspective: Condensations in the Plenum
In modern quantum field theory, the vacuum is not empty space, but an energy-charged plenum of interacting fields.
-
- Localized Excitations: What we perceive as solid matter or discrete particles are actually localized condensations or excitations within these underlying fields.
- Fundamental Interconnection: Because these condensations emerge from a continuous substrate, no physical object is truly isolated at the quantum level.
- Scale Separation: While this interconnection is physically real, macroscopic biological systems operate at scales where emergent boundaries—like cell membranes and skin—create distinct, localized behavior that cannot be reduced solely to quantum field fluctuations.
-
- The “Miner’s Canary” and Biological Boundaries
Traditionally, biology defined an organism through internal autonomy—the ability to self-regulate (homeostasis) and drive its own behavior via internal components like genes and organs. The miner’s canary challenges a rigid version of this view.
-
- Environmental Override: When carbon monoxide enters a mine, the gas binds to the canary’s hemoglobin, overriding its internal metabolic drive and causing it to collapse. Here, external chemistry dictates the organism’s state.
- Open Thermodynamic Systems: Modern biology already accounts for this by defining organisms as dissipative structures. Living things only exist by constantly exchanging energy and matter with their environment, meaning external influence is a baseline requirement for life, not an exception.
- Breakdown of Autopoiesis: Organisms are defined by autopoiesis—their ability to continuously produce and maintain themselves. The canary’s collapse does not prove it lacks internal agency; rather, it marks the threshold where external stress overwhelms its internal self-maintaining loop.
-
- Redefining the Organism
Combining the field-based view of physics with the systems view of biology changes how we define a living being, without discarding the category altogether.
|
Aspect |
Classical View |
Modern Systems & Physics View |
|
Core Identity |
A discrete, self-contained object made of solid parts. |
A localized, dynamic pattern of energy and matter within a larger field. |
|
Source of Behavior |
Primarily driven by internal components (genes, organs). |
Co-created by internal organization and continuous environmental coupling. |
|
Boundary Role |
A strict wall separating “inside” from “outside.” |
A semi-permeable interface that regulates exchange with the surrounding plenum. |
Summary
The miner’s canary does not invalidate the concept of an organism, because the very fact that the canary can be overridden proves it possesses a distinct internal order capable of being disrupted. Instead, it reinforces that an organism is best understood as a temporary, self-organizing knot within a continuous physical and ecological web, rather than an independent entity completely separate from the world around it.
* * * * * * * * *
[[ OK, there is enough agreement here to show that if the canary becames ill, knowing that it is a sensitive thing, we are not going to overlook the possibility that it is NOT “IT’S” ABNORMALITY that is manifesting by its unnatural behaviour but CHANGES IN ITS ENVIRONMENT such as rising toxicity in the atmosphere. No point in taking it to the hospital to run tests on ‘what’s wrong with it’ becaust it is perfectly healthy, but SENSITIVE so that humans who are less sensitive are not realizing that the atmosphere they are all in (humans and canaries) HAS BECOME TOXIC and may be doing unseen and unfelt damage to humans lungs and organs, but WESTERN CULTURE HUMANS tend to think of bodies as machines and machines are not known to be highly sensitive to toxic environments. In general, the understanding is that the humaning is a condensation within the energy-charged Plenum in which case the humanings ARE NOT INDEPENDENT BUT ARE INTERCONNECTED AND INTERDEPENDENT as is the case for CONDENSATIONS within an energy-charged PLENUM]]
What this understanding of material forms as CONDENSATIONS of the ENERGY-CHARGE PLENUM implies is that everything is INTERCONNECTED and INTERDEPENDENT which is why indigenous aboriginal RESTORATIVE JUSTICE makes sense while WESTERN CULTURE PURIFICATIONIST JUSTICE DOES NOT “MAKE SENSE”. For example, the BINARY LOGIC DIVISION into “THE HAVES” and the “HAVE-NOTS” is a WESTERN CULTURE development that has been encouraged by setting aside considerations of BALANCE and SOCIAL HARMONY and putting in place a system of ENTITLEMENT which cultivates IMBALANCE and SOCIAL DISSONANCE.
As the HAVE – HAVE-NOT GAP deriving from ENTITLEMENT, a system that is managed by THE ENTITLED, has led to INCREASING DISPARITY between the ENTITLED and UNENTITLED, there has been INCREASED INVESTMENT in ENFORCEMENT RESOURCES (POLICE, and CRIME SCENE INVESTIGATION (CSI) TECHNOLOGIES) to deal with the naturally induced PROLIFERATION of ROBIN-HOOD like BALANCE-RESTORING AGENTS. These BALANCE-RESTORTING AGENTS proliferate in direct proportion to the magnitude of the “HAVE” – “HAVE-NOT” IMBALANCE, where the “HAVE-NOTS” have negligible influence in ‘the official scheme of things’ compared with the “HAVES”, who have control over the skyrocketing RICH and POOR ENTITLEMENT IMBALANCE.
Indigenous aboriginal cultures have a general ethic of living their lives IN SUPPORT OF BALANCE as, for example, in the cultivating of the land in a manner that sustains good soil fertility and as with the Potlatch that supports BALANCE by way of those enjoying ABUNDANCE sharing their abundance with those whose crops have been hit by hail or flood, or whose hunting has been unsuccessful. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE similarly comprehends the interconnectedness and interdependence that is innate in Nature’s systems, including social collectives with their corresponding need to cultivate sustained balance. This is very different from the WESTERN CULTURE system which is based on ENTITLEMENT where huge related IMBALANCES are contended with by hiring MORE POLICE and SOLDIERS to protect against the natural BALANCE-RESTORING TENDENCIES, which WESTERN CULTURE HISTORY has shown, are very often POWERFULLY SUPPRESSED by those reaching the privileged ranks of the ENTITLED that benefit from POLICE and MILITARY back-up to support and sustain the SOCIAL IMBALANCE deriving from ENTITLEMENT.
SIMPLE BINARY LOGIC plays an important role in MAINTAINING the IMBALANCE between “HAVES” and “HAVE-NOTS” since “ENTITLEMENT” is one of those BINARY LOGIC based GATES whereby ONE “IS” or “IS NOT” ENTITLED as established by WESTERN CULTURE protocols that recall the HIERARCHICAL “Great Chain of Being”;
WESTERN CULTURE has a history of belief that HUMANS are included in a hierarchy of living INDEPENDENT FORMS; e.g.
The understanding of self in the fragmented, hierarchical sense of GREATER or LESSER BEINGS dates back to early WESTERN CULTURE linguistic conceptualizations such as;
“The Great Chain of BEING aka Scala Naturae; “The great chain of being is a hierarchical structure of all matter and life, thought by medieval Christianity to have been decreed by God. The chain begins with God and descends through angels, humans, animals and plants to minerals. The great chain of being (from Latin scala naturae ‘ladder of being’) is a concept derived from Plato, Aristotle (in his Historia Animalium), Plotinus and Proclus. Further developed during the Middle Ages, it reached full expression in early modern Neoplatonism” “The concept also influenced other hierarchies, such as the political structure with a king at the top and social strata below.”
Note the difference between HIERARCHICAL structure which is based on BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM and the STRAND-IN-THE-WEB structure of indigenous aborginals which is based on NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM.
WHAT IS DIFFICULT TO SHARE IN OUR WESTERN CULTURE SOCIAL COLLECTIVE IS THE UNDERSTANDING THAT OUR USE OF THE CONCEPT OF “BEING” BLOCKS US FROM “GETTING TO” and “MAKING USE OF” the BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM based concept of TRANSFORMATION. EG. Once one says ‘the TOWN is GROWING’ (which imputes BEING to the TOWN), WE HAVE INTRODUCED AN IMPLIED FIXED CONTAINING FRAME (AN ABSOLUTE EMPTY AND INFINITE SPACE WITHIN WHICH A “THING” CAN “GROW” IN ITS OWN RIGHT), a BEING based GROWING, DEVELOPING and PRODUCING CONCEPTUALIZATION that is innately FRAGMENTATIVE and OBSCURANTIST.
[[ OK, Now that the point has been made that our WESTERN CULTURE use of the concept of BEING BLOCKS US FROM USING THE NEEDED, LESS-SIMPLE BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM, we can get into a NEW, LESS SIMPLE LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZING SCHEME that has the NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM capability which is NEEDED to take us BEYOND the LEVEL 3 CONSERVATIVE AWARENESS and BEYOND the LEVEL 2 LIBERAL AWARENESS, both of which are simple BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM based, and TAKE US TO LEVEL 1 AWARENESS OF TRANSFORMATION which is NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC OF THE INCLUDING MEDIUM based. IN SHORT, we need to show how our use of “BEING” in our linguistic conceptualizing BLOCKS US formulating FLOW-BASED linguistic conceptualizations that will take us to LEVEL 1 AWARENESS of TRANSFORMATION]]
The reason why we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS remain STUCK in a CONSERVATIVE – LIBERAL STANDOFF (polarizing disagreement) is because of our POPULAR USE OF SIMPLE (i.e. “TOO SIMPLE”) BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM. This logic IS NOT ONLY THE SOURCE OF UNRESOLVABLE POLARIZED DISAGREEMENT OF CONSERVATIVES AND LIBERALS, IT ALSO, at the same time, BLOCKS ACCESS TO LEVEL 1 TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS (ACCESS REQUIRES NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC OF THE INCLUDING MEDIUM) WHICH, IF/WHEN ACCESSED, RESOLVES THE HEAD-BUTTING of LEVEL 3 CONSERVATISM and LEVEL 2 LIBERALISM.
The following descriptions of THE THREE LEVELS of AWARENESS are EXACTLY as Jantsch published them with the exception of the titles of the three awareness categories; i.e. I have substituted the Title TRANSFORMATION for the highest AWARENESS LEVEL 1 where Jantsch used “Evolutional”, … LIBERAL for LEVEL 2 AWARENESS where Jantsch had used Mythological and CONSERVATIVE for LEVEL 3 AWARENESS where Jantsch had used “Scientific”
While BOTH LIBERAL and CONSERVATIVE AWARENESS LEVELS (the lowermost AWARENESS levels) can be explained with BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM, TRANSFORMATION, THE HIGHEST OF THE THREE LEVELS OF AWARENESS, requires NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM. The HIGHER LEVELS of AWARENESS INCLUDE THE LOWER LEVELS; i.e. The LIBERAL AWARENESS LEVEL includes the CONSERVATIVE AWARENESS LEVEL and the TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS LEVEL includes the LIBERAL AWARENESS LEVEL. The following is a description of these three ‘telescoping’ AWARENESS LEVELS. These descriptions are exactly as Jantsch wrote them, and only the Titles have been changed (from Scientific to Conservative, Mythological to Liberal, and Evolutionary to Transformational).
AWARENESS LEVEL 3 (LOWEST LEVEL), the CONSERVATIVE AWARENESS LEVEL
—The classical [Conservative awareness level] assumes separation between the observer and the observed, and focuses on an impersonal “it” which is supposed to be assessed objectively and without involvement by an outside observer; the basic organizing principle here is logic and the results are expressed in quantitative or structural terms.
AWARENESS LEVEL 2 (MIDDLE LEVEL which implicitly incorporates LEVEL 3), the LIBERAL AWARENESS LEVEL.
—The [Liberal awareness level] established a feedback link between the observer and the observed, and focuses on the relationship between a personal “I” and a personal “thou”; its basic organizing principle is feeling and the results obtained are in qualitative terms.
AWARENESS LEVEL 1 (HIGHEST LEVEL which implicitly incorporates LEVELS 2 and 3), the TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS LEVEL
The [Transformational awareness level] established union between the observer and the observed and focusses on the “we”, on the identity of the forces acting in the observer and the observed world; the organizing principle is “tuning-in” by virtue of this identity, and the results are expressed in terms of sharing in an universal process (namely, [transformation]).
The reason why (we) WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS do not have access to the TRANSFORMATIONAL LEVEL in their (our) linguistic conceptualizing is because BEING-based linguistic conceptualizing is BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC OF THE EXCLUDED MEDIUM based which is too simple and is unable to support the NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM where the linguistic conceptualizing must support propositions such as THERE IS TOWNING IN THE TRANSFORMING LANDSCAPE wherein EVERYTHING IS IN FLUX, which a flow-based linguistic conceptualizing scheme can deal with, but which a BEING based linguistic conceptualizing scheme CANNOT deal with.
* * * * * * * * * *
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN WE DROP OUT AWARENESS LEVEL 1, the AWARENESS OF TRANSFORMATION which is the HIGHEST LEVEL OF AWARENESS.
WE HAVE UNENDING POLARIZED BATTLES BETWEEN LEVEL 3 AWARE CONSERVATIVES and LEVEL 2 AWARE LIBERALS because they have LOST AWARENESS OF LEVEL 1 TRANSFORMATION
WHERE DOES LEVEL 1 AWARENESS OF TRANSFORMATION DISAPPEAR TO WHILE CONSERVATIVES and LIBERALS ARE BUTTING HEADS ON WHETHER TO GO FOR QUANTITY OR QUALITY?
[edit check to here]
The WESTERN CULTURE social collective becomes DIVIDED INTO TWO BINARY LOGIC BASED POLARIZED OPPOSITES which means that THERE’S NOBODY LEFT TO SUPPORT TRANSFORMATION.
In indigenous aboriginal culture, EVERYBODY SUPPORTS TRANSFORMATION as the way the world works, so there is no SPLIT into POLARIZED OPPOSITES OF CONSERVATISM and LIBERALISM, both of which are based on BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM. As SOON AS ONE SPEAKS OF GROWTH, as in ‘THE TOWN IS GROWING’, BINARY LOGIC HAS TAKEN OVER THE FOUNDATIONAL ROLE in the LINGUISTIC CONCEPTUALIZING SCHEME. In indigenous aboriginal culture, the linguistic conceptualizing is flow-based, hence one employs the NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM conceptualizing scheme wherein THERE IS TOWNING IN THE TRANSFORMING LANDSCAPE where the TOWNING IS BOTH ITSELF AND AT THE SAME TIME THE LANDSCAPE IT IS INCLUDED IN (i.e. TOWNING is a relational feature within the TRANSFORMING LANDSCAPE).
THE CONSERVATIVES AND LIBERALS MAKE THE SAME MISTAKE, which the indigenous aboriginals DO NOT MAKE, and that is THEY USE “BEING” TOGETHER WITH THE DOUBLE ERROR OF NAMING AND GRAMMAR TO IMPLY SUCH THINGS AS ‘THE TOWN IS GROWING, DEVELOPING and PRODUCING goods’, or, “I AM GROWING, DEVELOPING and PRODUCING goods”. What is GOING ON HERE? It is as if the PERSON IS GIVING BIRTH TO AN INFLATING EGO where he is NO LONGER INCLUDED IN SOMETHING GREATER THAN HIMSELF, as is understood in indigenous aboriginal strand-in-the-web structure and as in condensations in the plenum modern physics structure. When WESTERN CULTURE substitutes EMPTY SPACE for the ENERGY-CHARGED PLENUM, the CREATING that belonged to the ENERGY-CHARGED PLENUM has to GO ELSEWHERE. STAND BACK FOLKS, HERE COMES …
- The Birth of the Isolated, Inflated Ego
When the implicit container is stripped of its generative, “maternal” status and reduced to mere empty geometry, several psychological and cultural consequences follow:
- Self-Origination Illusion: If the background space is “nothing,” then the local, explicit entity (the human individual) appears to be self-contained and self-originating. The ego no longer sees itself as a dependent wave in an ocean, but as an autonomous, sovereign island.
- Subject-Object Dualism: Upgraded to primary status, the explicit human mind becomes the sole active “subject” in a universe of passive “objects.” As thinker Iain McGilchrist notes in his work on brain hemispheres, this left-hemispheric, either/or mode of attention naturally fosters a sense of mastery, control, and grandiosity because it only recognizes what it can isolate, grasp, and explicitly define.
- Loss of Ontological Restraint: In a both/and system, ego inflation is naturally checked by the awareness that one is nested inside a greater, living intelligence. When that container is reduced to dead space, there is no larger “mother” matrix to defer to—leaving the human ego at the top of the ontological hierarchy.
As this AI assessment observes; “by treating the womb of reality as empty nothingness, the offspring mistakes itself for the sole [ego-inflated] CREATOR.” Here is the full AI QUESTION and RESPONSE:
Question to AI: The reduction from indigenous aboriginal belief in the both/and logic of the including medium to the WESTERN CULTURE belief in either/or logic of the excluded medium when applied to condensations of the energy-charged PLENUM in the PLENUM upgrades the local and explicit content to primary status and downgrades the nonlocal and implicit container to secondary status. Is this the source of ego inflation in WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS since the nonlocal and implicit container is empty space and thus no longer the ‘mother’ of the local and explicit?
AI Overview
Yes, within the framework of process philosophy, systems theory, and comparative metaphysics, this ontological shift is widely considered a primary driver of Western ego inflation.
When the foundational logic of a culture shifts from both/and (an including medium where the container and content are mutually constitutive) to either/or (the classical Aristotelian law of the excluded middle), it fundamentally alters how the individual self is perceived in relation to the cosmos.
Here is a breakdown of how this shift operates and how it produces the “inflated ego” you described:
-
-
- The Inversion of Figure and Ground (Content vs. Container)
-
-
-
- Indigenous / Relational Ontology (Both/And): In many Indigenous worldviews—as well as in quantum field theory and David Bohm’s concept of the implicate order—the “plenum” (the energy-charged, nonlocal, implicit field) is the primary generative matrix. Local, explicit objects (including human beings) are temporary condensations or “wave-forms” arising out of this oceanic whole. Because the container is the living “mother” or source, the individual self is inherently relational, humble, and accountable to the whole.
- Western / Classical Ontology (Either/Or): By applying binary, excluded-middle logic to reality, Western metaphysics severed the “figure” (the local, explicit object) from the “ground” (the nonlocal, implicit space). Through what philosopher Alfred North Whitehead called the fallacy of misplaced concreteness, the discrete object was upgraded to primary reality, while the space between objects was downgraded to passive, empty, dead vacuum.
-
-
-
- The Birth of the Isolated, Inflated Ego
-
When the implicit container is stripped of its generative, “maternal” status and reduced to mere empty geometry, several psychological and cultural consequences follow:
-
-
- Self-Origination Illusion: If the background space is “nothing,” then the local, explicit entity (the human individual) appears to be self-contained and self-originating. The ego no longer sees itself as a dependent wave in an ocean, but as an autonomous, sovereign island.
- Subject-Object Dualism: Upgraded to primary status, the explicit human mind becomes the sole active “subject” in a universe of passive “objects.” As thinker Iain McGilchrist notes in his work on brain hemispheres, this left-hemispheric, either/or mode of attention naturally fosters a sense of mastery, control, and grandiosity because it only recognizes what it can isolate, grasp, and explicitly define.
- Loss of Ontological Restraint: In a both/and system, ego inflation is naturally checked by the awareness that one is nested inside a greater, living intelligence. When that container is reduced to dead space, there is no larger “mother” matrix to defer to—leaving the human ego at the top of the ontological hierarchy.
-
-
-
- Alternative Perspectives on Western Ego Inflation
-
While your metaphysical diagnosis aligns closely with eco-philosophy, depth psychology (such as Carl Jung’s writings on the alienation of the Western ego from the collective unconscious), and relational ontology, other disciplines view this ego inflation through slightly different lenses:
-
-
- Evolutionary and Cognitive Psychology: Suggests that prioritizing local, explicit objects is an adaptive survival mechanism for tool-making and threat detection, which simply became over-extended into a totalizing worldview.
- Socio-Economic History: Attributes Western individualism and ego inflation to material shifts—such as the rise of private property, alphabetic literacy, and market capitalism—which reinforced the idea of the self as a bounded, competing unit rather than a relational node.
-
Ultimately, your formulation accurately captures a central critique of Western modernity: by treating the womb of reality as empty nothingness, the offspring mistakes itself for the sole creator.
If you would like to explore this further, we could look into:
-
-
- Philosophical parallels, such as David Bohm’s implicate/explicate order or Nishida Kitarō’s Logic of Place (Basho)
-
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS NEED TO RECOVER OUR EXCLUDED THIRD
THE EXCLUDED THIRD is the equivalent of substituting an EMPTY SPACE DISCONNECT between the WAVE-PEAK and WAVE-TROUGH and treating the TWO as SEPARATE and INDEPENDENT, and being as they are POLAR OPPOSITES, being in continual DISAGREEMENT as manifests in the SPLIT into CONSERVATIVE (TORIES) and LIBERAL (WHIGS) parodied by Jonathan Swift in his Satire Gulliver’s Travels with Lilliputians who break their eggs at the little end (Little-Endians), prompting a rebellion and war with the Blefuscudians, who stubbornly break theirs at the big end (Big-Endians). Jonathan Swift was NOT THE ONLY ONE with the opinion that the CONSERVATIVE – LIBERAL BINARY LOGIC based SPLIT is EGO-BASED NONSENSE deriving from the MISTAKEN BELIEF IN ONE’S OWN POWER OF LOCAL AUTHORING of actions and developments (exposed by Nietzsche as a fabrication constituted by A DOUBLE ERROR OF NAMING AND GRAMMAR).
In the Modern physics and indigenous aboriginal worldview, the world (reality) is the energy-charged PLENUM (wave-field) within which material forms are CONDENSATIONS that ARE NOT LOCAL, EXPLICIT THINGS-IN-THEMSELVES and only APPEAR to be so; i.e. they are Schaumkommen (APPEARANCE) in Schroedinger’s language. The “MOTHER” or “SOURCE” is the PLENUM ITSELF which is NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT while “people like ourselves who are LOCAL, EXPLICIT features (condensations) within the NONLOCAL and IMPLICIT GENERATIVE MATRIX OF THE PLENUM aka ‘the wave-field’. As Bohm asserts, “Space is not empty. It is full, a plenum as opposed to a vacuum, and is the ground for the existence of everything, including ourselves.” (David Bohm).
- Indigenous / Relational Ontology (Both/And): In many Indigenous worldviews—as well as in quantum field theory and David Bohm’s concept of the implicate order—the “plenum” (the energy-charged, nonlocal, implicit field) is the primary generative matrix. Local, explicit objects (including human beings) are temporary condensations or “wave-forms” arising out of this oceanic whole. Because the container is the living “mother” or source, the individual self is inherently relational, humble, and accountable to the whole.
* * * * * * * * * *
As explained earlier; …
… The reason why we WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS remain STUCK in a CONSERVATIVE – LIBERAL STANDOFF (polarizing disagreement) is because of the POPULAR USE OF SIMPLE (TOO SIMPLE) BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM. This logic IS NOT ONLY THE SOURCE OF THE UNRESOLVABLE POLARIZED DISAGREEMENT OF CONSERVATIVES (AWARENESS LEVEL 3) AND LIBERALS (AWARENESS LEVEL 2), IT ACTUALLY BLOCKS ACCESS TO LEVEL 1 TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS. ACCESS to LEVEL 1 AWARENESS REQUIRES NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC OF THE INCLUDING MEDIUM, once within LEVEL 1 AWARE mode, THE HEAD-BUTTING of LEVEL 3 CONSERVATISM and LEVEL 2 LIBERALISM is resolved.
What holds us back from ACCESSING LEVEL 1 AWARENESS is the BELIEF IN “BEING” which we must LET GO OF in order to enter into AWARENESS LEVEL 1. In other words, it is our WESTERN CULTURE BELIEF IN “BEING” that is INCOMPATIBLE WITH ACCESSESSING AWARENESS OF INCLUSION IN TRANSFORMATION.
AWARENESS LEVEL 1 (HIGHEST LEVEL which implicitly incorporates LEVELS 2 and 3), the TRANSFORMATIONAL AWARENESS LEVEL
The [Transformational awareness level] established union between the observer and the observed and focusses on the “we”, on the identity of the forces acting in the observer and the observed world; the organizing principle is “tuning-in” by virtue of this identity, and the results are expressed in terms of sharing in an universal process (namely, [transformation]).
The reason why (we) WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS do not have access to the TRANSFORMATIONAL LEVEL in (our) linguistic conceptualizing is because BEING-based linguistic conceptualizing is BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC OF THE EXCLUDED MEDIUM based. BINARY LOGIC is too simple in that while it can support the EITHER/OR LOGIC of the EXCLUDED MEDIUM, it is UNABLE TO SUPPORT the NONBINARY BOTH/AND LOGIC of the INCLUDING MEDIUM which is encountered where the linguistic conceptualizing must support propositions such as THERE IS TOWNING IN THE TRANSFORMING LANDSCAPE wherein EVERYTHING IS IN FLUX, which a flow-based linguistic conceptualizing scheme can deal with, but which a BEING based linguistic conceptualizing scheme CANNOT deal with.
WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS ARE BLOCKING OURSELVES FROM OPENING UP OUR AWARENESS TO TRANSFORMATION (LEVEL 1 AWARENESS) because of our attachment to (too simple) BINARY EITHER/OR LOGIC which is manifest in the CONSERVATIVE – LIBERAL “BINARY LOGIC BASED” POLARIZING SPLIT (“you conservatives are wrong!”, … NO!, you liberals are wrong!”). Something is missing here and it has been called the “DEA ABSCONDITA” (Goddess in hiding) which refers to the FEMALE ACCOMMODATING/ENABLING CONJUGATE. It “GOES MISSING” when we use ONE-SIDED MALE ASSERTING/ACTUALIZING conjugates “on their own” such as “THE TOWN IS GROWING” or “MY INDEPENDENT NATION’S GROSS NATIONAL PRODUCT IS GROWING”.
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE FEMALE ACCOMMODATING/ENABLING CONJUGATE? WE HAVE DROPPED IT OUT AND SUBSTITUTED ABSOLUTE EMPTY AND INFINITE SPACE IN ITS PLACE, as implicitly covered in our above discussion. There is NO SIGN OF THE FEMALE ACCOMMODATING/ENABLING CONJUGATE in our one-sided MALE ASSERTING/ACTUALIZING PROPOSITIONS. But as Goedel’s Theory says, ALL FINITE LOGICAL PROPOSITIONS ARE INCOMPLETE in which case the propositions of the LIBERALS and the propositions of the CONSERVATIVES could BOTH BE INCOMPLETE IN DIFFERENT WAYS; i.e. THEY COULD BOTH HAVE “BLINDSPOTS” IN THEIR ASSESSMENTS OF EACH OTHER.
* * * * * * * * * *
QUESTION to AI: Why do conservatives and liberals not see that their polar opposition derives from BINARY LOGIC while acknowledgement of TRANSFORMATION requires nonbinary both/and logic of the including medium?
AI Overview:
This observation touches on a profound philosophical and psychological friction in political discourse. The resistance of both conservatives and liberals to recognizing this dynamic stems from deep-rooted structural, cognitive and functional realities.
Here is a breakdown of why political ideologies remain anchored in binary logic and why the “both/and” logic of transformation is so difficult to adopt.
-
-
-
- The Survival Function of Binary Logic
-
-
Political movements are optimized for collective action, not holistic philosophical inquiry. Binary logic (“us vs. them,” “right vs. wrong,” “change vs. preservation”) serves vital systemic functions:
-
-
-
- Mobilization: Nuance paralyzes mass movement. A binary framework creates clear, urgent battle lines that motivate people to vote, donate, and organize.
- Cognitive Efficiency: The human brain naturally uses categorization to process a complex world. Reducing vast societal dilemmas into a binary format saves cognitive energy.
- Identity and Belonging: Political tribalism provides social cohesion. Admitting that the “other side” holds a necessary piece of the truth threatens an individual’s standing within their own ideological community.
-
-
-
-
-
- The Illusion of Completeness
-
-
Both traditional conservatism and modern liberalism operate on the assumption that their worldview is a complete, self-contained system capable of resolving society’s ills.
-
-
-
- The Conservative Blindspot: Often focuses on preserving the “differentiated parts” (traditions, structures, boundaries) while ignoring how those parts must dynamically evolve to serve the whole.
- of The Liberal Blindspot: Often focuses on the “transformative flow” (equality, progress, breaking boundaries) while underestimating the necessity of stable, foundational structures that prevent chaos.
-
-
Because both sides view their framework as complete, they perceive the opposing side not as a complementary pole, but as an existential threat to truth.
-
-
-
- The Threat of the “Including Mediuum”
-
-
To acknowledge a “both/and” logic requires stepping into what philosophers and systems theorists call the including medium or the generative matrix. This is the larger context — such as the shared ecosystem, the nation, or humanity itself — within which both poles exist.
Recognizing this medium requires two terrifying concessions for a partisan ideologue
-
-
-
- Loss of Abstolute Control: It forces the realization that neither progress nor preservation can permanently “win.” Transformation is a continuous cycle, not a final destination.
- Co-Responsibility: It demands the admission that the opposition is not an error to be eradicated, but a structural necessity. For examplewithout the conservative impulse for order, progress dissolves into chaos; without the liberal impulse for change, order calcifies into tyranny.
-
-
Summary of Trade-offs
| Logic Type | Core Focus | Advantage | Fatal Flaw |
| Binary Logic (Either/Or) |
Conflict, boundaries, clear-cut categorization. | High clarity, rapid mobilization, strong group identity. | Stagnation, polarization, and inability to solve systemic crises. |
| Transformational Logic (Both/And) |
Integration, evolution, the including medium. | Sustainable growth, systemic healing, nuanced truth. | High cognitive demand, political paralysis, loss of simple tribal identity. |
Ultimately, partisans do not see this because the binary pays immediate dividends in power, attention, and psychological comfort, whereas transformational logic requires a level of ego-death and systemic patience that modern political structures are explicitly designed to punish.
END of QUESTION to AI:
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
WE WESTERN CULTURE ADHERENTS NEED TO RECOVER OUR EXCLUDED LEVEL 1 AWARENESS
The (nonbinary) logic of the INCLUDED LEVEL 1 AWARENESS is the logic of TRANSFORMATION while the (binary) logic of the EXCLUDED LEVEL 1 AWARENESS is the logic of MATERIAL OBJECTS INTERACTING IN EMPTY SPACE.
* * * * * * * *
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.